Home

A few weeks ago I went on a trip to Italy to celebrate my birthday along with my #YOBA crew. That’s the ‘Year of Being Ace’ for the uninitiated – an initiative which was founded in 2023 as three of its members turned 40 and decided that the only thing for it was a year long celebration of our aceness through a series of Bacchanalian adventures.

That itinerary for the trip was organised by cousin Matt, who lives in Italy and was keen to show us a restaurant that claims to make Italy’s greatest pizza. The competition to be crowned as ‘Italy’s greatest pizza’ or ‘the world’s best pizza’ is as very hot one, and keenly contested. We thought we better check it out and see what all the fuss was about.

Franco Pepe’s eponymous restaurant ‘Pepe in Grani’ is situated in Caiazzo, a small town about an hour’s drive north of Naples. We had a late booking (late by English standards, I must add) and had to wait in an entry hall for 45mins or so to get our table. This place is phenomenally popular and tables are hard to come by. Eventually we were shown to a table and got ready to get stuck in.

The interesting thing is that ostensibly this is both a simple pizza restaurant – and also something much more ambitious. There are local people who come here to get amazing pizza, and then there are foodies who travel here from far and wide (like us!).

We were keen to see what the fuss was about so we went for the full shebang – their Evoluzione tasting menu which features 13 course pizza tasting menu! What’s the opposite of ‘no carbs before Marbs’…?! 

It starts with a ‘fried cone’ which featured a cornetto of pizza dough stuffed with molten Grana Padana cheese and topped with shavings of truffle. I mean, start as you mean to go on, right?

Full disclaimer time now! We were then bombarded – in the best possible way – by a cavalcade of pizza arriving in relatively rapid succession (the interval did slow slightly towards the end, which was much needed). It was also a busy and noisy restaurant and so I wasn’t really able to hear much of what was being presented, or take proper notes. As such, I won’t be going in to a detailed pizza-by-pizza summary. I did take photos though (#obvs) so they act as a nice memory-jogger of what we had.

After that we had two pizza brought out which were deep-fried pizza (“pizza fritta”, which is the other Neapolitan pizza style that they are famous for. Obviously most people think of the thin-style pizza which is now ubiquitous; but the fried pizza produces this slightly doughier, crisper version that was loaded up with beautiful toppings.

After this, we were then treated to seven (!) more traditional style pizza, which showcased various different elements. One that stood out was the Franco Pepe’s famous ‘La Margherita Spagliata’. I’m sure many of you will be familiar with a Negroni Spagliato – the ‘Spagliata’ element refers to it being ‘broken’ or done wrong. In this case Pepe’s playful take is to make a cheese base to the margherita pizza and then add in a concentrated tomato sauce on top, the reverse of a traditional magherita pizza. The sauce was gorgeous and it really worked.

Other memorable elements included one pizza slice that came with burrata and an olive oil dipping sauce. There was also another pizza that had some wonderful tuna on it garnished with spring onions. There were also some really decadent cheese-heavy pizzas that simultaneously thrilled you with their deliciousness and made you worry about your cholesterol levels.

Just when you might be thinking ‘jeez they must have to roll you out of there after all of that’, they then tell you that they are going to bring you not one, but two pudding pizzas. I mean seriously now. Both had sweetish (but not too sweet) bases, the first with a fruity, creamy style; and the second with caramel and cream.

We had a damn good go at all the courses. I tried them all and they were all absolutely delicious – but you can probably imagine that by the end we were feeling a little like Mr Creosote in ‘The Meaning of Life’ (a dated reference I know, but the most appropriate). The other factor for me was having started to eat so late, this was now midnight or so. I just can’t be doing with eating that late!

Whether this is the best pizza in Italy (or the world) others will have their say on – and be better informed. This was a really brilliant meal. Each pizza was interesting, different, tasty, and well-made. The tasting menu showcased their range wonderfully. I would definitely consider going here just to order a specific pizza and wash it down with a nice bottle of wine. The tasting menu is an experience worth doing, but just make sure you haven’t eaten for a few days beforehand…! 

Leave a Reply